"Answering A Question On Apostasy"
Jarrod Jacobs
This author received a letter from a woman asking about the impossibility of apostasy. She
believes that once a person has been saved, he/she can never be lost in Hell regardless of what
he/she may or may not do. She wrote me and asked my position on this. The portion of her letter,
and my answer pertaining to the possibility of apostasy, are below for your study. Please study
these verses for yourself that you might know the will of God better (Acts 17:11; II Tim. 2:15).
Her letter to me:
... Resting the doctrine of eternal security on one scripture passage tears my heart open. II
Peter 2:20-21. To think that someone is considered a christian because he has the knowledge of
Christ or having known the way of righteousness is ludicrous. If Peter meant saved bretheren why
didn't he state so clearly? I have witnessed to countless people throughout my 19 years as born again
christian. Many have received Christ but there have been many that have rejected the truth, they now
have the knowledge of Christ and they absolutley know the way of righteousness, but they are lost
and without hope. Trying to win these people only becomes harder and harder as their heart turns
further from what they know. I'm am 100 percent certain that this is what Peter (actually God) is
saying to us. What scares me is the fact that if you believe you can lose your salvation, what kind of
partial salvation do you have. "Not everyone who says 'Lord Lord'..." if you catch my drift. You
know what Ephesians 2:8-9 says. Will you not be boasting to God that you were able to keep
yourself from sinning whatever sin it was that was going to take your salvation away??? food for
thought. By the way John 10:27-30 clearly states it is Gods job to keep you saved not yours. Read
the Lords prayer in the Garden. (its not your job). With Love,
My response:
Hello ______,
Concerning your letter, you said, .... "Resting the doctrine of eternal security on one
scripture passage tears my heart open. II Peter 2:20-21." ....how many times does God have to
say something before it is true? If we can find one passage in the New Testament that teaches that
a Christian can sin and fall from grace, then the rest of the New Testament must harmonize. There
is no contradiction in the Bible.
Further you state, "If Peter meant saved bretheren why didn't he state so clearly?" With
all due respect, how much clearer did Peter have to be than to speak of those who "have escaped the
pollutions of this world"? This is not speaking of someone who merely heard the truth and then
rejected it outright. This is speaking of one who is a Christian. Notice that Peter says, "they are again
entangled" (v. 20). One could not become "again entangled" if they had never been untangled,
could they? Therefore, the ones under consideration were those who had become Christians,
untangled from this world, but then have become "again entangled AND OVERCOME." These
people, at one point, knew the "way of righteousness" but they "turned from the holy
commandment." This is not speaking of one who was never a Christian, for one who has never been
a Christian hasn't turned TO the holy commandment, yet.
Again, you say, "What scares me is the fact that if you believe you can lose your
salvation, what kind of partial salvation do you have."Not everyone who says 'Lord Lord'..."
if you catch my drift." Yes, I catch your drift. Now, if someone starts off right, doing the Lord's
will (Matt. 7:21), but stops and starts following his own way instead of the "way of righteousness"
(II Peter. 2:20), what then? Will he be saved, anyway? If someone turns their back on the Lord, after
having been a "born again Christian" for some time, what then? Will God have to just shrug His
shoulders and accept that person, anyway? Concerning partial salvation, I have no knowledge of that.
The Bible talks of salvation (Titus 2), and that is what I have.
"You know what Ephesians 2:8-9 says. Will you not be boasting to God that you were
able to keep yourself from sinning whatever sin it was that was going to take your salvation
away???" No, I will not boast. I have no room for boasting, for "when ye shall have done all those
things which are commanded you, say, We are unprofitable servants: we have done that which is our
duty to do" (Lk. 17:10). When we do exactly and only what God says, we have no room for boasting
in any form. I can avoid sin through the help of Almighty God (I Cor. 10:13), and not by my own
power.
"By the way John 10:27-30 clearly states it is Gods job to keep you saved not yours."
I have read John 10:27-30 just as you suggested, but found no statement akin to what you said. The
words "hear," and "follow" are verbs of action (v. 27). Christ is saying that one who continues to
"hear my voice" and continues to "follow me" are those who have eternal life. Now, what if one
stops hearing Christ? What if one stops following His word? Are they saved, anyway? If one is lost
in Hell, is it God's fault? Remember: II Peter 3:9.
"food for thought." Let me give you some food for thought concerning whether or not a
Christian can so sin as to be lost in Hell. Besides II Peter 2:20-21, which we have discussed, consider
and study the following:
1) Paul wrote to the Galatian CHRISTIANS and said: "Christ is become of no effect unto
you, whosoever of you are justified by the law; ye are fallen from grace" (Gal. 5:4).
2) Jesus said: "If ye continue in my word, then are ye my disciples indeed; And ye shall know
the truth, and the truth shall make you free" (Jn. 8:31-32). What if one does not continue in His
word? What of those DISCIPLES in John 6:66?
3) Paul said: "But I keep under my body, and bring it into subjection: lest that by any means,
when I have preached to others, I myself should be a castaway" (I Cor. 9:27).
4) Paul wrote to the Galatian CHRISTIANS and said: "Brethren, if a man be overtaken in
a fault, ye which are spiritual, restore such an one in the spirit of meekness; considering thyself, lest
thou also be tempted" (Gal. 6:1). Why would he be worried about this if it is impossible for a
Christian to so sin as to be lost? Why is he concerned if, as you said, it is God's job to keep you
saved?
5) Paul told Timothy: "Now the Spirit speaketh expressly, that in the latter times some shall
depart from the faith, giving heed to seducing spirits, and doctrines of devils" (I Tim. 4:1). Now,
when one departs from the faith, will he go to Heaven or Hell? Remember, you cannot depart from
a place you are not. (They could not "depart from the faith" unless they are a part of "the faith,"
i.e., Christians.)
6) Paul told Timothy that some: "Having damnation, because they have cast off their first
faith..... For some are already turned aside after Satan" ( I Tim. 5:12, 15). Doesn't this explain it
very clearly? Some had cast off their first faith (i.e., Christians) and faced damnation. Need we
consider any more? Isn't this the exact thing that Peter was saying in II Peter 2:20-21? Of course, it
is.
7) The Holy Spirit says: "Take heed, brethren, lest there be in any of you an evil heart of
unbelief, in departing from the living God" (Heb. 3:12). Again, one cannot depart from God unless
he/she had been in a close relationship with Him (i.e., Christians). This is a warning of what could
happen if they were not careful.
I hope that these passages will help you in your study. Please feel free to write back, and in
your next letter, ... tell me what you did to become a "born again Christian" as you so state.
Have a good day.
Sincerely,
Jarrod Jacobs
Addendum: The woman wrote me back one more time. In her letter, she never discussed a
single Scripture I presented. In fact, she made the point of saying she would not use any Scripture.
Her attitude was that we ought to just "agree to disagree." Sadly, I have not heard from her since.
There are many out there searching for the truth. Some are like this woman, wishing to have
her opinions justified by others. Jesus met the same types of people while he was on the earth (Jn.
2:24-25, 6:64). Yet, this did not stop Him from teaching and preaching the word to whomever would
listen (Lk. 19:10; I Tim. 1:15). There are still many others honestly searching for the truth. Jesus
taught the parable of the sower (Matt. 13) for this reason. Yes, there are those who are searching for
people to justify their beliefs; but there are many more searching for the truth.
With this in mind, let us open our Bibles, and learn the truth and obey it while we have today.
* Related Articles *
Back to Common Questions - Bible Answers